Border Collies: The Ultimate Guide to Training and Care - Dog Hugs Cat

Border Collies: The Ultimate Guide to Training and Care

Border Collies have a long and fascinating history that spans several centuries. As one of the most popular working dog breeds, Border Collies are famous for their intelligence, agility, and herding prowess. These traits and behaviors, and Border Collies as a breed, result from generations of selective breeding. Join us on a journey as we briefly explore the history and development of the Border Collie breeds into the furry friends we know and depend on today.

1. The Origin

The Scottish Borders, specifically the counties of Northumberland, Cumberland, and the Scottish Borders, are where the Border Collie's ancestors first appeared. To work with sheep, these dogs' herding skills were initially developed. Due to the demand for highly competent and adaptable herding dogs in this demanding and harsh environment, the Border Collie evolved.

For a visual representation of the areas Border Collies originate from, check out the map of The United Kingdom below, highlighted in forest green.

1.1. Early Development

Shepherds in the borderlands of England and Scotland started deliberately breeding dogs with excellent herding abilities in the 18th and 19th centuries. The extraordinary accuracy with which these canines could steer and regulate the movement of the herd of sheep while "crouching" earned them much respect. It was common to call these early Collies "working collies" or "farm collies."

1.2. Breeding of Working Dogs

Borderland shepherds understood the value of dogs with remarkable herding abilities. They developed a particular breed of dog that demonstrated the characteristics required for efficient sheep management through generations of selective breeding. These qualities included intelligence, situational awareness, ability to follow instructions, and agility. This was the beginning of the selective breeding that led to the Border Collies as we know them today.

1.3. Influence of Different Breeds

Although the origins of the Border Collie are unclear, it is thought that different herding dog breeds and kinds played a role in its evolution. Dogs used to create Border Collies were likely a combination of regional collies, such as the Scotch Collie, and other working breeds with a reputation for herding prowess, like the Welsh Sheepdog and the Old English Sheepdog.

2. Selective Breeding and Traits

Shepherds started giving particular traits more weight in their breeding plans as time passed. They were looking for dogs with a strong "eye," the Border Collie's renowned fierce and concentrated gaze. Instead of using physical force to control the sheep, this eye allowed the dogs to do it using visual cues. Additionally, the canines showed a crouched or stalking tendency that allowed them to approach the sheep up close without alarming them.


Border Collies' development through selective breeding is evidence of people's desire to create dogs with particular characteristics to serve their needs. Choosing dogs with desired traits to reproduce and transferring those features to their progeny is known as selective breeding. This method establishes unique breeds like the Border Collie and improves specific qualities through generations.

2.1. Early Stages of Selective Breeding

In the area where the breed was developed, on the border between England and Scotland, shepherds understood the need for expert herding dogs to control their flocks of sheep. They started selectively breeding canines with high work ethics, intelligence, agility, and natural herding tendencies. Dogs exhibiting these ideal characteristics were chosen as breeding stock, while those not used for reproduction.

2.2. Working Characteristics as the Primary Focus

Early Border Collies were designed primarily for their working prowess, unlike many other breeds created with particular appearances in mind. The main objective was to breed dogs that were exceptional at herding and could successfully handle sheep in the challenging and varied terrain of the border region.

2.3. Eye and Crouching Behavior

One of the most distinctive traits of Border Collies is their intense "eye" – the focused and mesmerizing gaze they use to control sheep. This characteristic was established through selective breeding to improve the canines' capacity to affect and communicate with sheep. This characteristic was praised because it made the dogs better at herding.

Additionally, selective breeding improved the typical crouched or stalking tendency of Border Collies. This behavior enabled the dogs to approach the sheep up close without alarming them, which was essential for effective herding. If you’re having trouble imagining what that looks like in practice, check out this video!

2.4. Intelligence and Adaptability

Border Collies were developed to be extremely intelligent and obedient to directions. Dogs that could swiftly comprehend and follow complicated rules were highly coveted by shepherds. Given the dynamic and unpredictable nature of sheep herding, it was also essential to have the ability to solve problems and adapt to diverse herding scenarios.

2.5. Breed Recognition and Standardization

The working prowess of Border Collies has led to increased breed standardization and the emergence of numerous sheepdog events and trials. These occasions allowed the dogs to demonstrate their abilities and helped establish the breed's standards. Breeding material was chosen from dogs with excellent herding skills to maintain and improve these features.

2.6. Balancing Traits

When choosing breeding partners, many attributes have to be balanced. Herding prowess was necessary, but other aspects, including temperament, health, and physical characteristics, were also considered. In addition to being skillful, a good Border Collie must also be teachable, agreeable, and physically able to handle rigorous labor.


2.7. Continued Selective Breeding

Border Collies are still bred with an emphasis on their working prowess. There is a difference between display lines, which are produced for conformation to breed standards, and working lines, which are bred for herding. The Border Collie working lines continue to be generated for intelligence, agility, and a strong work ethic, upholding the breed's history as a breed of exceptional herding dogs.


The requirement for superior herding dogs led to centuries of selective breeding that produced Border Collies. A breed noted for its intellect, agility, and herding ability was created by selecting dogs with the best working attributes to reproduce.

2.8. Breed Characteristics

Border Collies are recognized for their keen gaze, also known as the "eye," which they use to manage sheep. They are brilliant, agile, and hardworking. Although the length and color of their coat might vary, they typically have double skin that protects them from various weather situations.

2.9. Working Capabilities Over Appearance

Unlike many other breeds, Border Collies were primarily bred for their working qualities. This contrasts with many other species, which were established emphasizing appearance and conformance to foster standards. The breed's intellect and adaptability are greatly influenced by this focus on utilitarian characteristics rather than beauty.


3. Border Collies We Know Today

The characteristics that make Border Collies such great herders and companions also make them excellent competitors. All of these have been celebrated with a rich history of festivals and competitions, not to mention being loved as members of countless families.

3.1. Name and Recognition

It's thought that the term "Border Collie" was first used to identify these working dogs from other local collie breeds in the late 19th century. The breed's abilities were immediately acknowledged and rose to prominence in herding competitions such as sheepdog trials.

3.2. Sheep Herding Traditions

Many towns between England and Scotland's border practiced sheep husbandry as a way of life. The environment was made up of moorlands, rolling hills, and rugged regions that needed to be navigated by trained herding dogs to control flocks. These dogs are required to be strong and intelligent and have an instinctive awareness of sheep behavior.

3.3. Sheepdog Trials and Standardization

In the late 19th and early 20th centuries, sheepdog trials, which assess a dog's herding skills in controlled settings, gained popularity. The dogs with the best herding abilities were chosen for breeding, which had a considerable impact on the standards of the Border Collie breed. The breed's intellect and adaptability were influenced by the emphasis on working capacity over aesthetics.

3.4. Spread and Modernization

As sheep farming increased and the demand for talented herding dogs increased, Border Collies became well-known outside their native countries. The breed's flexibility was also used in other working capacities, including agility, obedience, and search and rescue.

3.5. Recognition and Pedigree

The American Kennel Club (AKC) in the United States and the International Sheep Dog Society (ISDS) in the United Kingdom have given the breed official recognition. However, the difference between working Border Collies and show-line Border Collies must be understood. Herding prowess is prized in working Border Collies, although conformity to breed standards may be more essential to show-line pups.

4. Work, Preservation, and Accolades

Despite their fame and acclaim, many Border Collies are still employed as herders on farms worldwide. To maintain the breed's distinctive qualities, efforts must be made to preserve its working prowess, intellect, and health.


Due to their excellent intelligence, adaptability, and working skills, Border Collies have garnered prizes and medals in various industries. Here are some accolades and contests where Border Collies have won top honors:

4.1. Sheepdog Trials

Border Collies are arguably best known for their accomplishments in sheepdog trials. These tests evaluate a dog's capacity to lead and guide a herd of sheep along a predetermined course or set of activities. Due to their high work ethic, intelligence, and sharp herding instincts, Border Collies routinely win these competitions. The International Sheep Dog Society (ISDS) trials and the United States Border Collie Handlers Association (USBCHA) trials are significant sheepdog trial contests.

4.2. Agility Competitions

Border Collies are recognized for their athleticism and agility. They perform exceptionally well in agility contests, where dogs must maneuver around obstacle courses, including jumps, tunnels, weave poles, and more. In these competitions, they stand out due to their rapid comprehension and execution of complex tasks.

4.3. Flyball

A team relay race known as "flyball" requires dogs to jump over hurdles, activate a spring-loaded box to release a tennis ball, and then return to their handler carrying it. Speed, intelligence, and excitement in Border Collies have helped them win flyball events.

4.4. Obedience Trials

Border Collies excel in obedience trials due to their intellect and eagerness to learn. These contests evaluate a dog's capacity to reliably and precisely carry out numerous commands and tasks.


4.5. Search and Rescue

Due to their agility, endurance, and excellent sense of smell, Border Collies have proved successful in search and rescue efforts. They are renowned for their capacity to find the missing in various environments and circumstances.

4.6. Herding Demonstrations and Shows

Border Collies are frequently included in herding demonstrations and shows at agricultural festivals and concerts. They are fascinating to watch as they expertly and precisely manage sheep, and they are praised for their herding abilities.

4.7. Dog Sports

Border Collies compete and do well in a variety of dog sports, such as canine freestyle (dance with dogs), dock diving, and frisbee tournaments. Their adaptability and passion for picking up new abilities help them succeed in these pursuits.


Although Border Collies are lauded for their successes in various competitions, their true passion resides in their working prowess, notably in herding. Many Border Collies are still used as farm dogs today, demonstrating their remarkable herding abilities and assisting the agricultural sector.

5. Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

What do I need to know about owning a Border Collie?

Border collies need a lot of activity and mental stimulation. Without it, they could start becoming destructive in their boredom. They're also prone to separation anxiety, so they don't work well in homes where they're left alone for the majority of the day. They need a lot of attention from their family.

Is a Border Collie easy to take care of?

They are a herding breed and need to have a job to do. Border Collies are also very smart. Therefore, they require a lot of mental stimulation. They have been known to herd other pets in the household or even children, so training, socialization, and consistent mental stimulation are essential with a Border Collie.

Why are Border Collies not for first-time owners?

As one of the dog world's most intelligent breeds, Border Collies are quick learners. Combined with their eager-to-please nature, training a Border Collie is fairly easy, but their high energy and intelligence mean they're not the best choice for first-time owners.

What are the cons of Border Collies?

Border Collies Pros and Cons 2022 Border collies can be very restless dogs. They have the need to want to do something and are often described as "jittery." Being able to constantly mentally and physically drain these dogs can prove to be quite challenging. If you live a busy lifestyle I do not recommend getting a border collie.

Why are Border Collies not good family dogs?

Border Collies are known for their loyal, intelligent, and energetic nature. They are affectionate dogs that make great family pets. However, their herding instincts can get in the way of socializing with strangers and young children, and they can be big barkers when on alert at home.

6. Conclusion

The history of Border Collies is intertwined with the development of efficient herding dogs in the border regions of England and Scotland.

Their intelligence, versatility, and herding skills have made them beloved working companions and competitors in various dog-related activities.

Thou these traits make them one of the most striking additions to any family needing an extra pair of eyes to help with the animals around the farm; their herding instincts can get in the way of socializing with strangers or even young children.

Leave a comment